I am trying to see whether a legitimate translation can make a true statement of a sentence that seems to
perhaps say something that is false. The sentence to be translated is:
Nota tamen quod Henricus Deffiat habuit Sun Jupiter & Mars in Aries & octava domo, & periit morte violenta
ob Mars, judiciaria ob Jupiter, & publica ob Sun; quia haec combinatio quadrabat infortunio Mercury domini
Horoscopi, ac medii Coeli, a Saturn in decima domui octavae inimico, suoque aspectu inficiente Sun Jupiter & Mars.
(The names of planets and signs are in English because the Latin text uses astrological glyphs. )
It would be false to say: "because this combination was squaring the misfortune of Mercury," or anything else that
would say that the combination of the Sun, Jupiter and Mars squares Mercury. Saturn squares Mercury, but
those three planets do not.
I have doubts about my proposed translation, especially because the best true statement I know how to get from the
Latin interpolates the word "and." Is there a way to get a true statement with a legitimate translation and
without an interpolation?
My current translation is:
Note, however, that Henri d’Effiat had the Sun, Jupiter and Mars in Aries in the eighth house,
and died a violent death from Mars, a judicial one from Jupiter, and a public one from the Sun—
because of this combination [and] the misfortune that Mercury, ruler of the Horoscope and of
the Midheaven, was squaring Saturn, unfriendly to the eighth house in the tenth house, its own
aspect infecting the Sun, Jupiter and Mars.
Thank you in advance.
perhaps say something that is false. The sentence to be translated is:
Nota tamen quod Henricus Deffiat habuit Sun Jupiter & Mars in Aries & octava domo, & periit morte violenta
ob Mars, judiciaria ob Jupiter, & publica ob Sun; quia haec combinatio quadrabat infortunio Mercury domini
Horoscopi, ac medii Coeli, a Saturn in decima domui octavae inimico, suoque aspectu inficiente Sun Jupiter & Mars.
(The names of planets and signs are in English because the Latin text uses astrological glyphs. )
It would be false to say: "because this combination was squaring the misfortune of Mercury," or anything else that
would say that the combination of the Sun, Jupiter and Mars squares Mercury. Saturn squares Mercury, but
those three planets do not.
I have doubts about my proposed translation, especially because the best true statement I know how to get from the
Latin interpolates the word "and." Is there a way to get a true statement with a legitimate translation and
without an interpolation?
My current translation is:
Note, however, that Henri d’Effiat had the Sun, Jupiter and Mars in Aries in the eighth house,
and died a violent death from Mars, a judicial one from Jupiter, and a public one from the Sun—
because of this combination [and] the misfortune that Mercury, ruler of the Horoscope and of
the Midheaven, was squaring Saturn, unfriendly to the eighth house in the tenth house, its own
aspect infecting the Sun, Jupiter and Mars.
Thank you in advance.